Sinai and Synapses Sinai and Synapses
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Our Staff
    • Our Mission and Methods
    • Why It’s Needed
    • About Clal
    • Scientists In Synagogues
      • About Scientists in Synagogues
      • Apply Now!
      • 2022 Selected Congregations for Scientists in Synagogues
      • Past Selected Congregations for Scientists in Synagogues
    • Sinai and Synapses Fellowship
      • 2021-2023 Sinai and Synapses Fellows
      • Sinai and Synapses Fellowship
      • Sinai and Synapses Fellowship Alumni
    • Science Education for Jewish Professionals
    • Sites We Like
    • Advisory Board
  • Content and Resources
    • Blog Posts
    • Down the Wormhole
    • Sacred Science
    • More Light, Less Heat
    • Discussion Forum
      • Are We Using Technology or Is Technology Using Us?
      • Why Do People Do Bad (And Good) Things?
      • Are We More Than Our Genes?
      • When Religion Heals, When Science Heals
      • How Science Influences Religious Language
      • God’s Creation And Our Creation
    • Content Resources from Scientists in Synagogues
  • Events
    • Upcoming Events
    • Past Events
    • Bring Rabbi Mitelman to Your Community
  • Contact
  • Support Us
Connecting…
Home Content Are We Using Technology or is Technology Using Us? Connecting…
  • Content
  • Topics
    • Are We More Than Our Genes? 16
    • Are We Using Technology or is Technology Using Us? 16
    • Astronomy 30
    • Awe 32
    • Behavior 67
    • Belief 59
    • Cognitive Science 40
    • Compassion 24
    • Consciousness 6
    • Creativity 16
    • Environment 34
    • Ethics 50
    • Fear 23
    • Free Will 5
    • Genetics 25
    • God's Creation and Our Creation 22
    • Gratitude 9
    • Happiness 11
    • Holidays 50
    • Hope 12
    • How Science Influences Religious Language 18
    • Learning 49
    • Mathematics 9
    • Memory 18
    • Morality 46
    • Prayer 19
    • Relationships 42
    • Religion and Science 119
    • Sacred Science 50
    • Scientists in Synagogues 107
    • Self 29
    • Sinai and Synapses Fellowship 30
    • Success 8
    • Technology 47
    • Theology 31
    • Time 24
    • Truth 27
    • When Religion Heals, When Science Heals 18
    • Why Do People Do Bad (and Good) Things? 28
  • Speakers
    • 2013-2015 Sinai and Synapses Fellows 53
    • 2015-2017 Sinai and Synapses Fellows 53
    • 2016-2017 Scientists in Synagogues Selected Congregations 26
    • 2017-2019 Sinai and Synapses Fellows 68
    • 2019-2021 Sinai and Synapses Fellows 20
    • Abby Olena, PhD 1
    • Adam Lyon PhD 1
    • Adam Reynolds 3
    • Agustín Fuentes PhD 1
    • Alan Lightman, PhD 2
    • Alfred Kaszniak PhD 1
    • Amanda Lawrence 1
    • Amanda Townley, PhD 2
    • Amy Herman 1
    • Amy Pollack 1
    • Anebel Hernandez 1
    • Anna McCallie 1
    • Annie Murphy Paul 1
    • Ariel Anbar, PhD 2
    • Arthur N. Popper, PhD 1
    • Arvin Gouw, PhD 7
    • Azi Grysman, PhD 2
    • Baba Brinkman 1
    • Barbara Hofer, PhD 1
    • Bonnie J Buratti PhD 1
    • Brian Gallagher 13
    • Brian Nosek, PhD 1
    • Briana Pobiner, PhD 3
    • Cailin O'Connor, PhD 1
    • Cantor Elizabeth Sternlieb 1
    • Carly-Anne Gannon 1
    • Carmen Del Toro 1
    • Carolyn Hall 1
    • Christian B Miller, PhD 1
    • Ciara Reyes-Ton, PhD 1
    • CJ Baldelomar 1
    • Connor Wood, PhD 24
    • Dan Rothstein 1
    • Dana Bash 1
    • Daniel H. Pink 1
    • Daniel Langton, Ph.D. 1
    • Daniel Wilkenfeld, PhD 1
    • Dave Schmelzer 2
    • David B Yaden PhD 1
    • David Borger Germann 1
    • David Bosworth, PhD 7
    • David DeSteno, PhD 7
    • David DiSalvo 1
    • David Haymer, PhD 1
    • David Mogul, PhD 1
    • David Novick PhD 1
    • David Rosmarin, PhD 1
    • David Snyder, MD 1
    • David Zvi Kalman, PhD 1
    • Debbi Dunn Solomon 1
    • Deena Gottlieb 1
    • Dennis Gilbride PhD 1
    • Derek Nelson 1
    • Diana Butler Bass 1
    • Dominic Packer, PhD 1
    • Dr Zachary Epstein 1
    • Dr. Adam Pryor 10
    • Dr. Andrea Ciaranello 1
    • Dr. Ashlynn S. Stillwell 4
    • Dr. Brian Patrick Green 1
    • Dr. Carey Murphy 1
    • Dr. Christopher Cotter 1
    • Dr. Elyssa Pellish 1
    • Dr. Gerard Saucier 1
    • Dr. Greg Samsa 2
    • Dr. Jennifer Wiseman 2
    • Dr. Joel Wolfson, MD 2
    • Dr. Jonathan Weinkle 1
    • Dr. Joseph Henrich 1
    • Dr. Joshua Greene 1
    • Dr. Joshua Holo 1
    • Dr. Joshua Weitz 1
    • Dr. Kevin Tidgewell 1
    • Dr. Michael Summers 1
    • Dr. Nicole M. Gerardo 1
    • Dr. Olga Kosheleva 1
    • Dr. Paul Slovic 2
    • Dr. Peter R. Saulson 5
    • Dr. Rebecca Newberger Goldstein 1
    • Dr. Stephen Rosen 1
    • Dr. Thomas Wassink 5
    • Dr. Victor J. Katz 1
    • Dr. Vladik Kreinovich 1
    • Dr. William Kraus 1
    • Elad Nehorai 1
    • Elaine Howard Ecklund, PhD 2
    • Elizabeth Fernandez, PhD 5
    • Ellen Knell PhD 1
    • Elliot Berkman, PhD 2
    • Emily Oster, PhD 2
    • Ethan Siegel PhD 1
    • Gale Sinatra PhD 1
    • Gary Heiligman PhD 1
    • Grace Wolf-Chase, PhD 2
    • Greg Cotsoona, PhD 1
    • Hank Davis, PhD 1
    • Helen de Cruz PhD 1
    • Helmut Brückner, PhD 1
    • Ian Binns, PhD 6
    • Ian Hutchinson, PhD 1
    • Imam Abdullah Antepli 1
    • Irene G. Plotzker, PhD 1
    • Isaac Alderman, PhD 4
    • Itzik Nir 1
    • Janet McDaniel 1
    • Jeremy England, PhD 2
    • Jerrold Davis, PhD 2
    • Joe Baldelomar 1
    • Joelle Novey 1
    • John Marc Sianghio, Jr. 8
    • John Meitzen, PhD 1
    • John Zaia, MD 1
    • John ZuHone, PhD 7
    • Jon Katz 1
    • Jonathan Morgan, PhD 9
    • Joselin Linder 1
    • Joyce Ann Konigsburg, PhD 1
    • Judith Donath, PhD 1
    • Judy Callahan 1
    • Judy Klinghoffer 1
    • Judy Libman 1
    • Julia Stoyanovich PhD 1
    • Julian de Freitas 1
    • Julie Reynolds, PhD 3
    • Julien Musolino 1
    • Karl Giberson, PhD 1
    • Kat Robison 10
    • Kate Stockly 2
    • Keith Shafritz PhD 1
    • Kendra Holt Moore 4
    • Kent Harber, PhD 1
    • Kevin Ladd PhD 1
    • Kim Regnier Jongerius, PhD 1
    • Kristine Henriksen Garroway, PhD 1
    • Larisa Heiphetz, PhD 1
    • Larry Lesser, PhD 2
    • Laura Donnelly 3
    • Laura Haynes 1
    • Laura Trouille, PhD 1
    • Lindsey Myers 1
    • Lisa Miller 1
    • Lisa Miller PhD 1
    • Lisa Ortuno, PhD 6
    • Lisa Sowle Cahill PhD 1
    • Lorenzo Cecutti 1
    • Lori Yanowitz 1
    • Luisa Cortesi, PhD 1
    • Mark Bloom, PhD 3
    • Marnie Gelbart, PhD 1
    • Marta Segal Block 3
    • Matthew I. Banks, PhD 2
    • Megan Powell Cuzzolino 1
    • Megan Powell Cuzzolino, EdD 11
    • Michael Dine PhD 1
    • Michael Gottlieb, PhD 1
    • Michael James, PhD 1
    • Michael Kaplan 2
    • Michael Shermer, PhD 3
    • Michael Zimmerman, PhD 1
    • Michelle Lani Shiota PhD 1
    • Miriam Brosseau 1
    • Mitchell Freedman, MD 1
    • Molly Shoichet, PhD 1
    • Muhammad Aurangzeb Ahmad, PhD 1
    • Myriam Renaud, PhD 4
    • Nathaniel Daw 1
    • Nicholas Christakis MD, PhD, MPH 1
    • Pastor Ken Wilson 1
    • Pastor Zach Fleming 1
    • Paul Root Wolpe, PhD 2
    • Pekka Sinervo, Ph.D. 4
    • Peter Hotez, MD, PhD 1
    • Professor Noah Efron 1
    • Rabbi Adam Bellows 1
    • Rabbi Adam Cutler 1
    • Rabbi Amy Hertz 1
    • Rabbi Andrew Paley 1
    • Rabbi Annie Tucker 2
    • Rabbi Ari Kaiman 1
    • Rabbi Arielle Hanien 6
    • Rabbi Avi Orlow 1
    • Rabbi Baruch Frydman-Kohl 2
    • Rabbi Ben Zeidman 1
    • Rabbi Benjamin Spratt 1
    • Rabbi Bradley Hirschfield 2
    • Rabbi Dan Ain 1
    • Rabbi Dan Geffen 1
    • Rabbi Daniel Nevins 2
    • Rabbi Daniel Swartz 1
    • Rabbi David Levy 2
    • Rabbi Dean Shapiro 2
    • Rabbi Debra Landsberg 1
    • Rabbi Dov Linzer 1
    • Rabbi Dr Joel Levenson 1
    • Rabbi Dr Karen Reiss Medwed 1
    • Rabbi Dr. Bradley Shavit Artson 3
    • Rabbi Dr. David Novak 1
    • Rabbi Dr. Jack Shlachter 1
    • Rabbi Elliot Dorff 1
    • Rabbi Emily Cohen 2
    • Rabbi Etan Mintz 2
    • Rabbi Fred Hyman 1
    • Rabbi Geoffrey A. Mitelman 199
    • Rabbi Gordon Tucker 1
    • Rabbi Ilana Schwartzman 2
    • Rabbi John Carrier 1
    • Rabbi Jon Spira-Savett 1
    • Rabbi Jonathan K. Crane, PhD 5
    • Rabbi Jordan Shaner 2
    • Rabbi Joshua Fixler 1
    • Rabbi Joshua Ratner 1
    • Rabbi Joshua Stanton 7
    • Rabbi Lawrence Troster 1
    • Rabbi Leah Citrin 1
    • Rabbi Lynne Goldsmith 1
    • Rabbi Margaret Frisch Klein 1
    • Rabbi Melanie Aron 2
    • Rabbi Michael Fel 3
    • Rabbi Michael Mellen 1
    • Rabbi Michal Loving 1
    • Rabbi Michelle Fisher 2
    • Rabbi Mitchell Berkowitz 1
    • Rabbi Nathan Roller 1
    • Rabbi Noah Fabricant 1
    • Rabbi Oren Hayon 2
    • Rabbi Rachael Jackson 14
    • Rabbi Rachel Ain 2
    • Rabbi Rachel Gurevitz 5
    • Rabbi Rachel Safman 2
    • Rabbi Robert Scheinberg 1
    • Rabbi Ruhi Rubenstein 5
    • Rabbi Shai Held 1
    • Rabbi Shmuly Yanklowitz 1
    • Rabbi Yaakov Jaffe 3
    • Rachel Petroff Kessler, RJE 1
    • Rachel Pincus 1
    • Randy Dimond, PhD 1
    • Razel Solow PhD 1
    • Razel Solow, PhD 1
    • Rebecca Lunstroth, JD, MA 1
    • Rebecca Saxe PhD 1
    • Rev Dr Gregory Simpson 1
    • Rev. Adey Wassink 1
    • Rev. Brian Sauder 1
    • Rev. Casey Ben-Aimé 1
    • Rev. Doug Hammack 1
    • Rev. Dr. Kara Slade 1
    • Rev. Dr. Kristel Clayville 4
    • Rev. Dr. Ruth Shaver 13
    • Rev. Gawain de Leeuw 4
    • Rev. Mark Goodman 4
    • Rev. Paul Raushenbush 1
    • Rev. Zachary Jackson 15
    • Reverend Dr. Eric Elnes 1
    • Reverend John Van Sloten 5
    • Reverend Rose Ann Vita 1
    • Rex Jung, PhD 1
    • Roald Hoffmann, Ph.D. 2
    • Robert Pollack PhD 1
    • Robin Coyne 1
    • Robyn Fivush PhD 1
    • Roger Price 1
    • Ross Ellenhorn PhD 1
    • Roy E. Plotnick, PhD 4
    • Ryan Niemiec, Psy. D. 1
    • Sam McNerney 1
    • Samuel Arbesman 1
    • Sara Gottlieb 9
    • Sara Huston Katsanis 2
    • Sara Seager, PhD 1
    • Sarah Chauncey, PhD 1
    • Sarah Goss 2
    • Seth Patterson 1
    • Seth Villegas 1
    • Shamila N. Chaudhary 1
    • Sharon Brown 1
    • Shira Leibowitz Schmidt 1
    • Sigal Samuel 1
    • Snezana Lawrence PhD 1
    • Stefanie West Leacock, PhD 4
    • Steven Goldman 1
    • Steven Pinker, PhD 2
    • Stuart Firestein, PhD 4
    • Tania Lombrozo, PhD 1
    • Ted Peters 1
    • Telli Davoodi, PhD 3
    • Thomas F Rosenbaum PhD 1
    • Thomas Williams 1
    • Tiffany Shlain 2
    • Timothy Maness, PhD 7
    • Val Snekvik 1
    • Venkat Venkatasubramanian 1
    • Victoria Templer Rotkow, PhD 1
    • Wayne Appelbaum PhD 1
    • William D. Richards 1
    • Yair Lior, PhD 1
    • Zander Harpel 1
    • Zane Fernandez 1
  • Months
    • March 2023 3
    • February 2023 3
    • January 2023 1
    • December 2022 5
    • November 2022 4
    • October 2022 5
    • September 2022 4
    • August 2022 5
    • July 2022 4
    • June 2022 5
    • May 2022 5
    • April 2022 4

Connecting…

  • November 7, 2017
  • Rabbi Rachel Gurevitz
  • Are We Using Technology or is Technology Using Us?, Scientists in Synagogues, Technology

Last week we kicked off a three-part mini-series on Technological Innovation and the Human Condition. The series is part of the ‘Scientists in Synagogues’ project run by my Rabbis Without Borders colleague, Geoff Mitelman. In each of the sessions, we have a congregant with expertise in some aspect of technological innovation or the impact of technology in our lives who presents on a topic. This is followed by small group conversations around tables, with supplementary Jewish texts and questions to help guide the discussion around the issues and ideas raised by the presentation.

In our first program, Mitch Diamond, a member who has worked with chip technologies (currently with Intel), had us consider what some of the underlying human impulses are that lead us to adopt or not adopt new technologies, and how we emotionally respond to the concept of new technologies taking over or transforming areas of our lives. Providing a context for how we tend to react to new technologies, whose impact we do not yet know and don’t generally do very well trying to predict, he introduced some wonderful historical examples. The debates we have about the impact of technology today are not, it turns out, anything new. Take this example from 1876, recorded in the New York Times:

“A patriotic regard for the success of our approaching Centennial celebration renders it necessary to warn the managers of the Philadelphia Exhibition that the telephone may really be a device of the enemies of the Republic.” What if every town in America got a phone, and never had to show up to celebrations like the Centennial in person again?

Today, many congregations have introduced live streaming technology into their sanctuaries. The result has not been, as some have feared, that people stop coming to the congregation. Rather, it has enabled those who otherwise could not access the spiritual experience, or who might not have chosen to access the experience by walking into a synagogue by themselves, to have a version of the experience.

We pondered whether a programmed robotic arm that can write a Torah scroll (a project that was brought to the Jewish museum in Berlin, albeit using paper and not parchment) could feasibly replace the art of the Sofer (the scribe). While most in attendance were clearly not in favor of such a development, articulating that it was about the intention, the spiritual meaning of the Torah and the craft involved in creating it, and how that was qualitatively different from the debate of the Fifteenth century when the printing press put thousands of scribes out of work, was not so easy.

Among some of the factors that surfaced in the conversations that followed the presentation were issues of genuine relationship and empathy. While in Japan, some have paid for a robot to perform funeral rites because the traditional priests are not plentiful enough and very expensive, most could not conceive of a Jewish funeral performed by a robot. The pre-funeral conversation and pastoral support provided by the rabbi were the qualitative parts of the experience that went beyond the functional. Likewise, doctors in our midst pointed to the human element that was essential to the doctor-patient relationship, even while recognizing that new technologies are helpful tools in making their diagnoses more accurate and enabling ever-more technical and fine detail procedures to be carried out that the human hand alone would not be capable of.

Discussing where technology and AI (artificial intelligence) can aid knowledge and where it can harm human understanding, we reflected on how, far too often, people will be uncritically accepting of information they read online (the ‘Google Effect’). Wisdom is the result of reading more broadly, and we tend to find information more efficiently in the high-tech age, but lose the incidental learning that happens when pouring over journals in a library as part of a research process. We are more likely to focus in on the information that fits with our pre-ordained assumptions and miss those ideas that are at variance with those opinions.

Interestingly, when the printing press was first introduced, many Christian clergy were against it because they were concerned about the democratization of knowledge if lay people could read scripture for themselves. However, while much of Jewish leadership was enthusiastic about the possibilities of this new technology, some of those who were against it had a different reason than the Christian clergy.

Magda Teter writes: ‘Like their Christian counterparts, some rabbis expressed strong reservations about the dissemination of knowledge through printing.  They feared that Halakhah and Kabbalah, unfiltered by rabbinic instruction, would be misunderstood if made widely accessible.  Some also feared that Halakhah would become overly rigidified because it would not be mediated by the discussion and debate that accompanied its creation and transmission in rabbinic circles.’ (source – http://jewishhistory.research.wesleyan.edu/ii-cultural-trends/1-printing/)

In other words, it was the relational experience of chavruta (study partners) in the yeshiva, where Jewish practice and law evolves through debate and group learning, that these rabbis feared would be lost if people read alone out of printed volumes, and this might overly rigidify the evolution of Judaism. Again, it is the relational aspect of the experience – that which is qualitatively about the connections between human and human – that were integral to the assessment of whether a technological innovation would bring about something positive or negative.

Ultimately, our reflections demonstrated that technology is neither a positive or a negative in its own right. We began to surface some of the practical, but more often emotional and spiritual aspects of connection that play a part in determining whether, when it comes to technological innovation, we truly want it. There may, in fact, be some things in life that are irreplaceable.

(This post is part of Sinai and Synapses’ project Scientists in Synagogues, a grass-roots program to offer Jews opportunities to explore the most interesting and pressing questions surrounding Judaism and science. This post is from Congregation B’nai Shalom of Westborough, Massachusetts, and originally appeared on My Jewish Learning‘s Rabbis Without Borders blog. It is also part of the Sinai and Synapses Discussion Forum, a collection of perspectives on specific topics. It is part of our series, “Are We Using Technology, or is Technology Using Us?“)

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading...
Tagged with Community, Congregation B'nai Shalom, Knowledge, presence, Rabbis Without Borders, Religion and Technology, Ritual, Robots
Previous
Character Strengths, Judaism and the Science of…
Next
Costly Truths and Valuable Deceptions: How…

0 Comments

Add a Comment Cancel

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

My Tweets

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

* indicates required

Events

Today

Apply for Scientists in Synagogues!

Scientists in Synagogues provides communities a $5000 grant, along with mentorship, guidance and connections, in order to run grass-roots programs that offer Jews opportunities to…
Apr 22

Torah Study with Rabbi Mitelman

  • 9:30 am – 11:00 am
Torah Study on Tazria-Metzora at Westchester Reform Temple.
Apr 28

Scholar-In-Residence Weekend with Rabbi Geoffrey A. Mitelman

Rabbi Geoffrey Mitelman is the Founding Director of Sinai and Synapses, an organization that bridges the scientific and religious worlds, and is being incubated at Clal – The…
© 2023 Sinai and Synapses.
Incubated at Clal
440 Park Avenue South
New York, NY 10016
  • Home
  • Our Mission and Methods
  • Blog Posts
  • Support Us
  • Contact
Today The Family Gene
Mar 16 What Does It Mean to Be a…
%d bloggers like this: