A Jewish Take on the Search for Extraterrestrial Life

A Jewish Take on the Search for Extraterrestrial Life

Growing up in the 1980s, Star Trek, Star Wars, and E.T. filled my imagination with the idea of extraterrestrial life. The fantasy Star Wars galaxy contains 3.2 billion habitable planets, supporting 20 million species of sentient beings. While scientists have indeed been searching for life in the universe, the question of life on other planets always seemed more a matter of science fiction than hard science.

Likewise, while Jewish thinkers have pondered the question of life on other planets, it never seemed very relevant, given the limited tools scientists had to answer this question. Even in rabbinical school in the 1990s, I never really thought much about the religious implications finding extraterrestrial life would have on Judaism. My understanding changed when I heard MIT Professor and exoplanet hunter Dr. Sara Seager describe science’s dramatic advances in the last 20 years.

Dr. Sara Seager believes we are closer than ever to answering the question, “Are we alone in the universe?” Dr. Sara Seager’s goal is to find and identify another Earth orbiting a sun-like star. In the past two decades, scientists have discovered thousands of exoplanets. This pace of discovery is remarkable, considering scientists only discovered the first exoplanet orbiting a sun-like star in the mid-1990s. Starting with the Hubble telescope in the late 1990s and the James Webb telescope in recent years, scientists can now study the atmospheres of exoplanets, giving data on those that could sustain life.

Is it possible that life exists beyond our planet? What would it mean if it did? What would it mean to religion? Does Jewish theology support the notion of a God that created other worlds?

Rev. Jose Gabriel Funes, an astronomer and former director of the Vatican Observatory, once observed, “If biology is not unique to the Earth, or life elsewhere differs bio-chemically from our version, or we ever make contact with an intelligent species in the vastness of space, the implications for our self-image will be profound.” Some theologians fear that the integrity of the biblical story of creation, which only mentions life existing in our world, would be questioned.

But Judaism has less of an issue. Many Jewish texts describe other worlds. The Talmud speaks of God flying through 18,000 worlds (BT Avodah Zara 3B). The Talmud even speaks of an inhabited planet or star called Maroz (Judges 5:23). Scholars have noted that Maroz sounds a little like Mars.

Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan, a prominent mid-20th century rabbi and kabbalist, went as far as to say, “The Midrash teaches us that there are seven earths. Although Ibn Ezra tries to argue that these refer to the seven continents, the Zohar clearly states that the seven are separated by a firmament and are inhabited. Although they are not inhabited by man, they are the domain of intelligent creatures.”

That said, like most things, the question of extraterrestrial life has been debated in Jewish tradition. Medieval rabbis argued about the possibility and desirability of life on other planets, some arguing that such a possibility would negate the Torah.

The late Dr. Velvl Greene was a bacteriologist with a secular, Zionist upbringing. In the 60’s, he became an Orthodox Chabad Jew. He is the perfect person to bring to our discussion today, as he was a religious person who sought to harmonize science and religion.

In the 1970s, Dr. Greene worked with NASA’s Planetary Quarantine Division, looking for life on Mars, particularly microbes that could hitch a ride back to Earth. Some Orthodox Jews told him to stop, saying that what he was doing was against the Torah.

Concerned, Dr. Greene asked the famous Lubavitcher Rebbe of blessed memory, Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson, if his work was appropriate for a religious Jew or if he should quit. The Rebbe answered: “You should look for life on Mars, and you should keep looking for life on Mars. If you don’t find it, then keep looking elsewhere, and do not stop looking, because to sit here in this world and say there is no life elsewhere is to put a limit around what G‑d can do. And nobody can do that!” The Jewish belief in a limitless God means there is no doubt in God’s ability to create other worlds.

Dr. David Weintraub, professor of astronomy at Vanderbilt University and the author of Religions and Extraterrestrial Life: How Will We Deal With It?, affirms that Judaism is spiritually prepared for little green men. “Judaism accepts the possibility of extraterrestrial life. Jewish theology may actually require a belief in extraterrestrials since there are no limits on the power of the creator. Thus, for Jews to say that no life beyond the Earth could possibly exist would be unacceptable, as such an idea would appear to place shackles on God’s creative power… the universe belongs to God and God can do what God wishes to do with the universe.”

That said, both the possibility of alien life and the possibility that we are alone in the universe create their own religious issues. First, what if we are not alone? After each day of creation, God looks upon what God created and says it was “Tov” – “Good.” This Divine response comes after God creates light, Earth, sea, animals, and plants. But the language changes slightly after the creation of the human on Day Six: “God saw all that God had made and found it Tov Meod, very good.” (Genesis 1:31). What is so very good about humans? What makes us special? Only humans are described as being created Betzelem Elohim – “In God’s image.” (Genesis 1:27). What if other creatures in the universe share this designation? What if we are not that unique and special? Would these other beings have their unique creation story, covenantal relationship with God, and sacred Torah-like texts?

Alternatively, we learn from Genesis that “It is not good (lo tov) for the Human to be alone; I will make a fitting helper for him.” (Genesis 2:18). Perhaps it is also lo tov – not good – for us to be alone in the universe. Judaism centers on community and connection; perhaps we would take comfort knowing that a universal community connects us to the same infinite and unifying God.

Fortunately, scientists like Professor Sara Seager have not stopped looking for life in the universe. Whatever they discover will have a profound impact on Judaism and the Jewish people.

(This post is part of Sinai and Synapses’ project Scientists in Synagogues, a grass-roots program to offer Jews opportunities to explore the most interesting and pressing questions surrounding Judaism and science. Dr. Sara Seager and Rabbi David held a talk as part of the “Science with a Shmear” series at Congregation Beth Elohim on December 17, 2023.)

One Comment

  1. Kfir

    Fascinating article. I saw the man in the video speak about this topic on the Chabad website. Let’s hope Hashem grants everyone who reads this article the “Hashem can do anything and everything” for that person and brings salvation to all who reads this article this.

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *