As images of the James Webb Telescope take hold over our imaginations, we may not realize the incredible engineering it required — and the community that built it. Michael Kaplan was part of the team at the beginning of the JWST project, and has also been involved in SpaceIL, both of which helped deepen his connection to Judaism. Recently profiled by The Jewish Chronicle, his work at NASA also connects to his Jewish life at Congregation Har HaShem in Boulder, CO, which was part of Scientists in Synagogues from 2018-2019.
Michael Kaplan is the Principal Consultant at Kaplan Astronautics, LLC located in Boulder, CO and has been working in aerospace, satellite and systems domains for over 35 years. While at NASA Headquarters, Michael created and led the development of several transformational programs including the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST), successor to the Hubble Space Telescope.
Watch Video
Geoff Mitelman: Welcome, everybody, to Episode 50 of Sacred Science. I am Rabbi Geoff Mitelman, founding director of Sinai and Synapses, which bridges the worlds of religion and science. And I’m very excited to be talking today with Mike Kaplan, who was one of the shepherds of the James Webb telescope, which we have been reading about and watching over the last few weeks. They just actually announced a new, a new image, I believe, of the Cartwheel Galaxy.
But Michael Kaplan is the principal consultant at Kaplan Astronautics, located in Boulder, Colorado. He has been working in aerospace, satellite and systems domains for over 35 years. And while at NASA headquarters, Michael created and led the development of several transformational programs – including the James Webb telescope, which is the successor of the Hubble Space Telescope. And he’s also a member of Congregation Har Hashem in Boulder, Colorado, which was part of Sinai and Synapses’ project Scientists in Synagogues a few years ago. So he’s been involved in both the scientist piece and the synagogue piece and involved with SpaceIL, I know, as well. So, Mike, thank you for taking some time to talk with us here this morning.
Michael Kaplan: Sure. I’m happy to be here, and it’s a pleasure. And by the way, I enjoyed this Scientists in Synagogues program. I gave a talk about the history of astronomy at Har Hashem in that context. So that was a lot of fun.
Geoff Mitelman: And it’s great, because you’re one of the people that we really love to talk to, because there are so many fantastic scientists who are members of synagogues, and they do all this great work professionally. And yet who they are professionally is very linked to who they are personally.
Michael Kaplan: Right.
Geoff Mitelman: So I’d love for you to share just a little bit of – you have a very interesting professional background and biographical background. I’d love for you to share a little bit about what your career trajectory has been, because you’ve been involved in Hubble, you’ve been involved in SpaceIL, you’ve been involved in James Webb, you’ve been involved in a lot of different really exciting initiatives here, right?
Michael Kaplan: Yeah, sure. So, to quote an old comedian, “I started off as a child,” right? So as a child, growing up in the 60s, it was a magical time, because we were in the race to go to the moon. And that was an incredibly inspiring experience. In fact, one of my earliest memories was – I’m not sure if it was John Glenn or one of the first original astronauts. After I saw that launch, I begged my parents to let me stay home from school. And to watch the launch, I had a process, had to drag a kitchen chair in front of the TV, flip the chair over on its back, because astronauts are sitting on their back when they’re getting ready to launch. And I’d watch the whole thing for hours, sitting on my back. And so that was my beginning in the space program.
But it’s kind of – I’m one of those lucky people who got to kind of fulfill the dreams of what they wanted to do when they were a – you know, did my undergrad at Princeton, aerospace engineering and physics. I almost went to astrophysics grad school, but instead, I decided to go work on the engineering side and worked for a decade at Naval Research Lab outside of DC, learning satellite design.
And I got tired of working in Defense stuff, so I got a job at NASA headquarters to run future astrophysics programs called Advanced Programs Branch Chief in Astrophysics. So my first day was the day that we discovered that the Hubble mirror was flawed. As I’m getting ready to go in – the Washington Post headline is, “Hubble Mirror Flawed.” And my wife says, “I think the market demand for your work has just taken a nosedive today.” And so it was strange day, but it was an amazing experience to be part of the team. We figured out, how do we fix the Hubble mirror?
But also, at that time, a lot of these large, very exciting space missions take a long time to happen. So – like, Hubble, even though it was launched in 1990, the thought process and the design started in the early 70s. Astronomers knew that was the case. So as soon as Hubble was getting ready to be launched, people were already looking at “What do we do after Hubble?” So the seeds were planted, and once we got Hubble kind of squared away with corrective optic systems. And Hubble has exceeded expectations after the repair and has been operating way beyond its design life. I engaged with that part of the science community, and we started thinking about, “What do we want to do after Hubble?” And the astronomers were rather conservative, and they decided they wanted a mirror that was about 4 meters in diameter. That’s how astronomers think about telescopes in terms of how wide the telescope is and what part of the spectrum – the electromagnetic spectrum. And they wanted it to work in the infrared. And the purpose was going to be to find baby galaxies. There was an astronomer named Alan Dressler who ran a committee called [HST & Beyond], and that was their recommendation. And I met with them, and I said, “Why 4 meters?” And they said, “Because that’s the biggest mirror we could fit in a rocket.”
And I said, “Well, you’re assuming that you can’t either unfold or build a mirror.” And they all started laughing. And at the time, NASA had a new administrator – Dan Goldin. He came over from what was then TRW – also a really sweet Jewish guy, very interesting and controversial guy, because he was very transformational. He liked upsetting the apple cart. He liked getting people to think differently about things. And it caused a lot of people heartburn. I resonated with that because that’s sort of one of my kind of taglines in terms of my career. And we had talked – I’d had several meetings with him. And we had talked about technologies that were developing that could enable you to what’s called segment the mirror.
And of course, we see my coffee mug – that’s the famous JWST mirror. That’s a segmented mirror. So I postulated to the team, “these are things are possible.” They still wanted to be conservative. So Dan – excuse me for going a little bit longer. This is a really interesting story about how things happen. I flew with Dan to an astronomy conference in Tucson, Arizona. And this was in 19… I think it was in ’90. Was it ’94? I think it was maybe ’94. And I’m sitting in the front row of the audience – Alan Dressler, the chair of that committee, sitting next to me. Wes Huntress, the head of NASA Science, is sitting next to me, and Dan’s up on the podium, and there are 3,000 astronomers waiting to hear what he has to say, because he’s the guy that’s going to fulfill their dreams of what we’re going to do after Hubble. And he says, “Alan, why only a four-meter telescope? We can go bigger, why not six?” And Alan says, “How about eight?” And Dan pounds his fist on the podium and he said, “Sold.” It was like an auction.
So that telescope was originally called NGST – the Next Generation Space Telescope. And it started out as an eight-meter telescope, and its design conditions were set at that meeting – very interesting. Dan wanted to – and he got a standing ovation. Everybody jumped up and Wes Huntress, the Head of Science, sit next to me, his hand to his head. Why was he upset? Because we know that cost for telescopes goes up – it’s not linear with size. It’s like diameter to the 2.4 power. So what Wes thought was going to be 4 meters, and it’s going to be now 8 is going to cost, like, 4 times as much. And he has to go figure out how to pay for it. So he saw his checkbook requirements go way up.
So, one of many interesting stories about how this started. But I was privileged to be part of that after seven years at NASA headquarters. And I got the program started, laid out the technology roadmap, figured out what inventions we needed to make to make it work. I spent a number of years in private industry, Ball Aerospace, who built the mirror for Webb, Boeing Space Systems, Loral.
I decided around 2010 to do something different. I made Aliyah, moved to Israel, tried to help out with SpaceIL. I did the best I could. My experience is that Israeli management culture is such that it’s difficult for someone who didn’t grow up there and go through the army to have any kind of influence, even though you know things they don’t know. So I moved back, although I did meet my wife there in Jerusalem.
So we decided to move back to the US in 2015. I’m in Boulder, Colorado, and now, I consult – actually the consulting business has kind of petered out. I now work full time for a company called LeoStella. I’m the VP of Business Development. LeoStella builds very small satellites. This is one of the new things in space is, we’re doing amazing things with very small satellites. So some of the pictures people see in the news of the Russia invasion of Ukraine. So a lot of those pictures are taken by black sky satellites, commercial satellites. We at LeoStella build those satellites. So it’s really interesting, and we’re hoping to build, improve weather prediction in the future and all these things. So that’s kind of an outline of my career path.
Geoff Mitelman: What’s interesting, of what you’re talking about, is that when we think about the results of things, we think about the awe and the majesty, right – the pictures from James Webb, the pictures from Hubble. For us, as laypeople, we see those, and we are just in awe of what’s created. And we don’t always think about the human elements of: What’s the politics of it? What’s the cost? Where do we build the relationships? That’s, I think, a forgotten element, which is that these things didn’t just come out of nowhere.
Michael Kaplan: That’s right.
Geoff Mitelman: They came out of not just the science, but there’s the engineering that happens. And the engineering are the very practical questions of how – as much as it’s going to cost, how are we going to find the money? How are we going to convince people to be able to do this? These are human questions.
Michael Kaplan: Excellent point. Excellent point. So, for example, we didn’t have all the parts laying around in labs, right? There were a lot of inventions. One of the ways I like to think about things is – one of the things that you first learn when you’re planning a new space project is there are some rules of thumb that have been learned over the decades of our experience working in space and building space hardware. And one of the things is: Minimize the number of moving parts. Now, why that? Because anything that moves needs a motor, and the motor can fail. So the minimal number of moving parts means the minimum number of failure modes. So the highest probability of success, if you think about it that way. So, the wisdom of Alan Dressler and the science committee to stick with a four-meter monolith (a “monolith” meaning a single piece of glass, although it wouldn’t be made out of glass, it would be too heavy, it’d be made out of something else, was that it wouldn’t have to be deployed and move).
So when Dan Goldin challenged us to move to this different type of an architecture, which required segmenting the telescope, first we had to figure out: Do you launch a stack of hexagons and have a robot arm – kind of like deal them out and assemble it? Do you fold it up like a tabletop – which is the way we ended up deciding to go?
We had to make those decisions. And we had never thought about things like that before. So we got the brightest minds we could possibly find, and everybody who knew anything about optics was just juiced to get involved with this. I had no problem recruiting the best and brightest of people in this country. And Europe quickly got involved. So the European Space Agency and the Canadian Space Agency, early on, got involved.
So we had to figure out, “how do you build the mirror,” right? And then the next question was – we knew it couldn’t be made out of glass, so we had to be made out of something else much lighter, because glass weighs a whole lot. If you ever try to pick up a big sheet of glass, and imagine if that glass is now, like, a foot thick and 24, 25 feet in diameter, you would need one big shuttle launch just to take the glass up, and then you need another one to launch the rest of the telescope. So that wouldn’t work. So there were all kinds of – we had to develop new types of materials and think about… so there are lots of things.
But the big tying-back to what I believe is one of your main themes is, it took a leap of faith to decide to go to a segmented aperture. And then the other piece here, it’s important to realize, is the mirror isn’t the only big challenge. The other challenge is when you want to work in the infrared, which is what we wanted to do, because to work in the infrared means you can go further back in time. You can see further out into the early universe and see the origin of galaxies, baby galaxies – see them being born, you need to work in the infrared. Well, to work in the infrared, you’ve got to be really cold, and I mean really cold. I mean a couple of degrees. The detectors, the sensors in the back of the cameras that sit in the back of Webb have active coolers. They’re cooled to a couple of degrees above absolute zero. But every optical surface that the light touches – the primary mirror, the secondary that where the lights reflected up, and it’s sent back and down into the guts of the telescope, where the cameras are – all those had to be cooled to 35 degrees Kelvin, which is 35 degrees above absolute zero.
So, to be really cold in space means you’ve got to be always in the dark. So we needed to have a big sunshade to keep the telescope cold. So that sunshade is the size of a tennis court. So how do you fit a tennis court in a rocket? Well, it’s got to be folded up somehow, or it needs to be inflated. Original thoughts were it would be an inflatable sunshade. So inflating, unfolding – more moving parts! So we had to shift from “minimize moving parts” to a new paradigm of “I love moving parts.” So if you love moving parts and you embrace it, what you have to do is you have to get the best people, the best designs – compete, compete, compete, practice, practice, practice. We had never done anything like this before. And people say, “Well, Webb ran way over budget.” It was supposed to be $2.5 billion. That was what the price tag when I originally sold it to OMB and the Congress, and then it came in a little over 10 [billion].
Well, the reason why the cost increases occurred was because as we learned more – this is the most complex thing humanity, I would argue, has ever built. As we learned more and more about the engineering challenges, as we go deeper and deeper into it, we needed to practice and rehearse and practice and rehearse. So there were, I would guess, probably seven to eight years of extra testing that were added on with a lot of people involved, and that’s why it costs more. But there was a leap of faith, because at the end, Hubble was launched, and the mirror was flawed – human error which should have been found. And fortunately, astronauts were able to go up and fix it. We put Webb up a million miles from the earth, and no humans can get there. So we had to have – It was a leap of faith that all the testing and all the work and all the dedication would pay off – because if any one of those things didn’t work – any one of the motors, cables didn’t work, failure – with no hope of fixing it.
And I remember it was an interview recently with John Mather, the Nobel Laureate from NASA Goddard, a brilliant scientist and a real mensch, the senior scientist of Webb – he was involved in the very beginning. He was asked recently, know before it was launched, “Do you have confidence that it’ll work?” And he said, “No, I don’t have confidence, but I have faith, because we had the best people.” And I believe what he really meant to say was, you know, “Our creator Hashem endowed us with this intelligence and this curiosity and this desire to do impossible things. And we did our best and we have faith that our best would work.”
Geoff Mitelman: And you know, the word of “faith,” at least in Hebrew, of emunah, is “trust.” And trust is based on – as you were talking about practice, as you’re talking, what it’s making me think about is this dynamic that happens in politics – it happens in religion. And it’s an important balance, which is the sort of progressive, liberal, hopeful element and the more conservative, staid, grounded element.
Michael Kaplan: No moving parts.
Geoff Mitelman: Right. And you need both of those, because if it’s just, “We’re keeping this as it is,” then there’s no dynamism. But if you jump too far ahead, then it’s sort of blind faith. You need to be able to say, “This is what my hope is going to be. This is why I’m moving in this direction, and this is why I’m grounding it in what we know,” – for Judaism or for politics, what my tradition has to say. “I’m not completely rejecting everything here. I’m saying this has been tested for, is that ten years? Is it 30 years? Is it 3,000 years? And what’s the reality right now? And what might come down the road?”
Michael Kaplan: That’s right. So it was really a synthesis of both, obviously. So we followed all best engineering practices. NASA has tried-and-true engineering management practices. All those were followed to the nth degree – reviews after reviews after reviews. But where the real faith, I guess, emanated from was the senior leadership at NASA bought off on our – was willing to take the challenge of doing this.
And at the time, the other thing that Dan Goldin did – the other big thing he did in the science area at NASA was at that time, all the planetary exploration, the probes that would go to Jupiter and Mars and Saturn, they were all big. He called them “Battlestar Galacticas” – multi-billion dollar projects that took 10, 15 years to occur. And he started a program to use smaller satellites. And the first rover on Mars is a perfect example of it. It was supposed to last, like, a month. I think it lasted like a year and a half, I believe – I might be mistaken. And most of the missions that we’re seeing that are going around Mars, the most recent pictures we’re seeing of Jupiter from the Juno probe, the Pluto mission – all of these emanate from that paradigm that Dan Goldin created. “Smaller, better, cheaper” was the moniker – or “faster, better, cheaper,” because they were shorter programs, and cost less, but in a sense that made life easier. The challenge was to see, could we do something good for only 300 million or 400 million, as opposed to, like, 3 billion?
The real leap of faith was on the astronomy side, because we knew you can’t make things smaller and do edge-of-the-universe frontier science that a great country like the US, only places like the US, you can tackle because of our industrial base and our scientific base. So that was the real big leap, because we had to make really large, complex things work in environments that there was no forgiving for mistakes we could not fix.
Geoff Mitelman: Well, when the pictures came out from the James Webb Telescope, one of the things that struck me was that everybody felt the awe and the wonder and the majesty of what was – and some of it is certainly artistic renderings, but even the astronomers, even the people working at NASA, looked like they were in awe of not just the image, but also that it worked.
Michael Kaplan: Well, so again, John Mather, when someone asked, “When you see the first images, what do you feel?” The first word out of his mouth was, “I feel very relieved.” But Webb is exceeding all the engineering and design requirements. And so the pictures – what that means is, the images are sharper, crisper, cleaner. The spectra we’re getting back are more precise. So it’s exceeding our expectations.
I don’t mean to diminish these feelings of almost awe and wonder and inspiration looking at these images. But I remember once Hubble was fixed, there were lots of Newsweek and Time covers that were Hubble photos. And there’s a very famous one – it’s called “Pillars of Creation.” You probably remember that image. And those were just amazing, because those were leaps beyond anything we’ve ever seen.
And now, of course, what we’re seeing is some of the imagery – and by the way, all the stuff we’re seeing from Webb now, this is all what we call low-hanging fruit. When the science program was put together, there was concern – it’s called “healthy concern” – that, what if Webb doesn’t quite measure up? What if there were some mistakes made? So let’s propose some science that’ll be easy for it to do.
The harder stuff for Webb, the real challenging, the real jaw-dropping stuff – is yet to come. So I’m just movie-teaser-trailer here – like, really, the best is yet to come. So these early images – and you see them compared – there have been a couple of images where they’ve shown an image of an area, and they’ve compared it to the Hubble image to see. It’s really startling. And it’s the fact that it’s optimized for the infrared. The aperture is much larger. A lot of observables are just significantly enhanced.
But by the way, Hubble’s still chugging along. And there’s a lot of really amazing science that’s being done with Hubble. And also, you know, Hubble was part of a program in astrophysics called the Great Observatories Program. And the idea there was to understand what’s going on in the universe, you need to look at objects across the electromagnetic spectrum. So Hubble was largely operating in the visible and ultraviolet light. There’s another telescope called Chandra, which is an x-ray observatory. Chandra is still observing, although it’s nearing the end of its lifetime. There was a telescope called the Compton Gamma Ray Observatory, observing in the highest energy regime – gamma rays. Gamma rays we observe like black hole events, supernova explosions, highly energetic events, emit a lot of energy in the gamma rays.
And then, finally, the last great observatory was another project that I helped start called the Spitzer Space Telescope. That was only an 80-centimeter infrared telescope. That was launched, I think, right around 2000, and that had a very limited lifetime. They gave us the first glimpse of what the infrared universe would look like with only an 80-centimeter optic. So, you know Webb is eight times the diameter; Webb is a leap beyond. But of those, two are still operating – Chandra and Hubble. And one of the things that astronomers are really excited to do is to do what we call panchromatic observations, which is looking with our new big infrared zoom lens – JWST, and these other telescopes – because when you combine all that information, then you really get deep physical understanding.
So, some people are saying, like, “Webb is the beginning of the greater observatories,” or the next generation or set of great observatories. And people are already starting to think about 15- and 20-meter telescopes that would be assembled by robots in space, launched – like almost built out of Lego pieces that way. And actually, maybe a more efficient way to do it, because you don’t have to do as much ground testing, because you would do the assembly, the integration and the testing on orbit – where would you do it? We would do it on commercial space stations that are now being designed and developed by commercial companies here in the US. NASA’s announced that the space station is going to be phased out toward the end of the decade. And there are a number of companies – Blue Origin, Sierra Space, Axiom, Nanorex – a number of companies are building what could be commercial space stations, and one of those stations could be designed as a big test facility for the next big astronomical telescope.
So not only is the best yet to come from Webb, but we see a path of where we’re headed in terms of our ability to understand and explore space. And we’re just getting started. And what’s exciting is a lot of that. I would say most of it is being driven by commercial, not by the government.
Geoff Mitelman: Yeah. That’s what’s able to be moving forward [versus] what tends to be a little more conservative. Like, the government tends to be, I’m sure, a little bit more conservative versus private industry.
Michael Kaplan: Right.
Geoff Mitelman: As we’re talking about being able to see that – origins of galaxies, and the origins of the universe, and these existential questions that we’re asking – I remember one of our scientists from Scientists in Synagogues worked at Fermilab, and we talked to him when the g-2 experiment came, which was also one of those questions of origins of the universe kinds of pieces. And I got to tour the particle physics laboratory.
And what it reminded me is there’s a line in Exodus when Moses goes up to Sinai and asks to see God, and God says, “You can’t see my face. You can only see” – the Hebrew is my ahorai, usually translated as “my back,” but a better translation is, “you can only see my afterwards.” And not only was that what we can see of the particle physics, but it also was reminding me of Hubble and James Webb, and being able to see deeper and deeper into deep time and deep space. We can only see these things afterwards. All these images that James Webb is showing us – those are not things that are happening now. These are things that happened billions and billions of years ago that we’re finding right now. And I’m curious as to how that – do you still feel that sense of incredulity when you see an image that – this was before the solar system formed?
Michael Kaplan: Yeah, this was before the “before.” It’s a spot-on question. I was told, because this happened a couple months before I arrived at NASA headquarters, that one of the things that kind of blew people away was, [with] Hubble. There was so much excitement before Hubble was launched. There were actually protesters at Cape Kennedy. That didn’t want Hubble launched because they were afraid Hubble was going to see God. When you do exciting projects in the government, and of course the taxpayers, the public, are the ultimate beneficiaries of whatever we do. You want them to appreciate what you’re doing. And sometimes maybe our PR machine maybe goes a little too far. I don’t think we went too far, but I think certain segments of the population got a little too excited, maybe hot and bothered, about what we were really trying to do.
But really, what I have found – and one of the blessings of working on just groundbreaking science projects like Webb, and some of the other missions I’ve been involved in – was you get to work with just the smartest and best and most eminent scientists there are in these fields, because we bring the best and the brightest to do these things.
And what I found is, there’s a fundamental sense of awe and wonder that each and every one of them have about what they’re doing, about the meaning of the results that they’re finding, their intensity to make sure that if they discover something, to make sure we get it right.
And I’m reminded of one of my favorite Carl Sagan quotes, which is, “Extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof.” So if someone makes an observation that the universe – we’re going to refine the number of the age of the universe from 13.8, which I think is the latest projection, to 13.9 or something – to do that requires a very rigorous, comprehensive peer-review process, which is really how science is done, which I think a lot of people don’t understand. Unfortunately, we live in an era where a lot of science is being questioned and rejected. And I think those who reject it, I think fundamentally don’t understand it – that our scientists, whether they’re astronomers, whether they’re doctors, epidemiologists, they’ll change their minds, not because somebody has told them to, but because they got more data, and now there’s a different conclusion. And of course, they vetted the new data before they announced. We have a different conclusion here. But there’s a fundamental driving force – it’s not just in their brains, it’s in their hearts – to get it right. To get it right, and advance human knowledge. And it’s a deep-held belief, and I would say it’s almost like a religious belief, because you can’t shake them from the process that they use – very much the same way that someone who’s deeply religious, you can’t shake their deep ties to their faith. It’s the same thing.
And last thing I would say on this topic is, a lot of the leading scientists that I’ve worked with are religious people as well. They don’t see a conflict at all. I’m sure this is probably a topic you’ve covered. There’s no conflict between science and religion. Webb isn’t going to tell us how the universe was created or who created it – it’s just going to tell us more about what we observe, about those steps. That’s what it’s going to teach us. That’s not in conflict with religion at all.
Geoff Mitelman: Well, I’d love for you to talk a little bit about your Jewish journey as well, because that’s one of the things you mentioned, of God giving us wisdom and knowledge. And that’s one of the things that happens in Judaism a lot, which is that more knowledge is better, right? Judaism has always celebrated questioning – opening new knowledge. I’d love for you to share a little bit about – if it does, how does your Judaism and your Jewish trajectory link with some of your astrophysical work that you’ve been doing?
Michael Kaplan: Yeah. Some of the links, I think, are subtle, but they’re certainly there, I think. I grew up in Baltimore, Maryland. Early on, I went to an Orthodox synagogue, but we eventually moved. And I had an Orthodox bar mitzvah, and then we moved to a Conservative synagogue. And unfortunately, like many American Jews, instead of the bar mitzvah being the start of your Jewish journey, unfortunately, for most people, it was the end. So it was sort of the end of mine. I would observe the holidays, but I really wasn’t very religious at all.
And then, over the decades, not much changed. I guess when I had kids, got a little more involved because I wanted them to go to Hebrew school. I wanted them to get a Bar Mitzvah and all these things.
But a curious thing happened for me along the way. My older son is autistic. My younger son had his bar mitzvah, then he went off and he went to college to study engineering. And I guess it was at the end of his freshman year or middle of the freshman year. I was divorced at the time. He reached out to us, and he said, “I’m considering converting to Christianity.” We found out he had been, I guess, associating with – I’m not sure. I called it an Evangelical Christian fraternity or whatever. They were welcoming him in. And his mom and I spent a lot of time kind of going, “What can we do?” And I talked to some 20-somethings that I was living around in Boulder then, and figured, well, “What can I do to awaken his Jewish soul?” And the consensus was, “Take him to Israel.” So during his winter break, I planned a trip – and I met with my rabbi.
At the time, I had also gotten involved with a Jewish Renewal community here in Boulder called Nefeh Kodesh. And so that was my synagogue. And I met with our rabbi. And the advice I got was, “When you go to Israel, don’t stay in hotels, stay in people’s homes, rent out rooms, because if you want a connection with the land, you want to be connected to the people, too.” And so I developed an itinerary – a couple days in Jerusalem. Then we went down to the Dead Sea, and then we went up to Zefat, we finished up in Zefat. It was an amazing experience. My son didn’t know that was the reason for the trip – like most Americans – was to awaken his Jewish self. “Hey, I’m going. Do you want to come with me?” He said, “Sure.”
So we went there, and we got settled. We stayed in the German colony in Jerusalem, walking distance to the Kotel. It was around 2:00, so – “let’s take a walk,” we walk to the Kotel. We arrive, know it’s a bunch of rabbis sitting around, and they’re asking, “Have you put on tefillin today?” That’s the question. They ask –“Are you Jewish? Have you put on tefillin today?”
So I said, you know, “I haven’t put on tefillin in a really long time.” Said, well, you know, see, you’re lucky – we’ll help you do that. And they turned to Jason – “Are you Jewish?” And if you put on tefillin today, he says that he’s never put on tefillin before. So the rabbi said – I said to him – “Really? You didn’t learn to do this as part of your bar mitzvah training? I’m surprised and shocked.” And the rabbi said, “You’re in luck. Guess what? We’re going to finish your bar mitzvah here today at the Kotel.” And he started crying, and I started crying, and I was thinking, “Ah, first Jewish soul-awakening experience.”
So we had a couple of other experiences like that along the journey. Unfortunately, that didn’t really work for him, but it worked for me, ironically – you know, Hashem works in very unexpected, strange ways.
So I got back home, and I met with my rabbi, and she looked at me and she said, “Something in you has shifted. Are you thinking about making Aliyah?” I said, “I don’t know about that, but I’m thinking about moving to Israel.” Of course, I didn’t know what Aliyah meant.
So I moved to Israel nine months later. I reached out to Nefesh B’nefesh. It turned out – so I did a lot of exploration of my Judaism when I was in Israel. Actually, for about six months, I did an experiment. I tried to live almost like a pure Orthodox life. I wanted to see what that was like. And it’s easy to do, because you don’t have to hunt far to find Kosher food. It’s easy to separate milk from meat. And I just found that wasn’t for me, but it was a deep spiritual awakening. And so all of that has stayed with me.
And I have to say I ended up moving back five years later, largely for professional reasons. And I alluded to that earlier. I didn’t find a willingness – I mean, I brought unique experience and expertise to the Israeli space industry. I was working with all the top people. I consulted with the director general of the Israeli Space Agency. I worked as a consultant for Elbit – big aerospace company there. I was consulted for three years for SpaceIL helping them try to have their mission be successful. And the engineers were real excited to learn and let me allow me to mentor and teach them.
The management thought they knew better. They thought this was a UAV. And it’s unfortunate. I mean, Beresheet could have succeeded. It was an exciting moment. It was an exciting time. I know the team is going to go back and try again, and I’m confident they’ll succeed the second time, but it’s unfortunate. So after five years, I decided to move back. But my faith – I’m more observant now than I was. I put on tefillin every day in the morning. I daven in the morning, and I find that grounds me. And that grounding has helped me find direction, not just in my life, but in my career as well. So it helped me take the leap of faith, of going – because my career had largely been working for what we call large legacy space companies – Boeing space systems, Lorel, Raytheon. These are big companies, very stable, very conservative, but they’re not blazing the trail of where we’re headed in space. And that faith and that grounding that I get from the davening every day gave me the courage and the wisdom to decide to – at this point in my career, I’m in my late sixties. People don’t normally plan career shifts.
Maybe back in the Bible days, people had career shifts in the late 60s, but not in these days, to work for a small emerging space company, LeoStella, and work in what people call the “new space world,” which is this new wave. So it’s given me the courage and wisdom to do that. And I found an amazing team, and I tap into that grounding and spiritual wisdom that I get every day. It fuels me every day.
Geoff Mitelman: Well, Mike, thank you for that biography in that sense. And that’s such a wonderful way to close, because that’s the role of religion, right? It’s not to give final answers. It’s not designed to end conversations. It’s designed to open conversations, and to give us a level of grounding and hope and connection.
And so I want to thank you, not just for your time, but also all the work that you’ve done to help us understand the universe better and to be able to work with people who can help us get a better sense of the universe and its origins and all the work that we can do to help improve our knowledge and to be able to improve. So, Mike, I can’t thank you enough for your wisdom and for your time and for your expertise.
Michael Kaplan: It was my pleasure, and I’ve been blessed with these career opportunities. And when you reached out to me about this, I was only happy to jump at the opportunity and to share the excitement and the joy that I’ve experienced, and also to help the viewers and listeners get a little more insight behind – peek behind the curtain, how these things happen. Yeah, decisions sometimes are made in kind of interesting and sometimes humorous ways. But there was an enormously dedicated team of people at NASA that pulled off Webb, and I’m eternally grateful. I just set it all in motion for those first seven years. There were some amazing leaders – Greg Robinson, who’s recently announced his retirement from NASA, did an awesome job the last several years bringing it home. Thomas Zerbuchen, the Head of Science, had faith in Greg, and there were many attempts to cancel Webb over the last decade. And the leadership team at NASA held steadfast. And we’re seeing the benefits of that every day. And everyone that’s watching this – keep your eyes peeled. The best is yet to come.
Geoff Mitelman: That’s a wonderful message. And I encourage people to follow James Webb telescope and to be able to follow all the work that NASA is doing. And people can follow us. We are on social media. You can find us at @SinaiSynapses on Twitter or me, I’m at Rabbi Middleman, and you can find us on Facebook. We can find more of these conversations at Sacred Science. We’re going to be taking a little break until probably the High Holy Days, but we will look forward to having more conversations with people over the next couple of weeks. And Mike, thank you for taking the time with us here today.
Michael Kaplan: My pleasure. And Shabbat Shalom.
Geoff Mitelman: Shabbat Shalom.
0 Comments